Friday, July 30, 2010

a comment

Below you will find (in its entirety) a comment recently posted to this blog by “dontplaydat”. Though it is heartfelt and well penned, we hope that the majority of our readers do not share the author’s sentiment. Its message is certainly not our intention for the blog or our year of nothing new. But, we’ll let you decided as we take solace in the old saying, “What people say about you is none of your business.”

~Stacey & Courtney

dontplaydat said...
"You know. Some of the posts here are really great, but lately, the more I read this blog, the more arrogant it seems to be. You have challenged yourselves not to buy anything new in 2010 and you gush about buying things second hand, and prosthelytize to the rest of us that we should do the same. While I am thrilled that you two have discovered a brave new world of thrift shops and yard sales, this is a way of life for hundreds of thousands of families across this country and nothing you are doing is remotely novel. It is only novel to you because up until this year you have been participating in good old fashioned American consumerism - something we are all brought up to believe in. I applaud the increased awareness about the pitfalls of capitalism that must have inspired this little project - but the hallmark wisdom lecturing that goes on in this blog is worse than saccharin; it's arrogant and makes you look silly. ESPECIALLY when there are so many posts on here where you end up getting what you need materially BECAUSE OTHER PEOPLE BUY IT FOR YOU. So you've really just come up with a way to mooch off other people and instead of calling it just that, you rationalize this contradictory little fact by saying it's the result of "secret energy" giving you what you need. The "secret energy" is your friends' time and money - get a clue. 
Another one of my favorites is buying a new dress for a wedding, and justifying it by saying that you agreed to be in the wedding long before the two of you conceived of this project. It must be really nice to have the money to just toss off playing poor when vanity calls. Tough titty that you decided to do the wedding before this project - buy a second hand dress OR (even MORE interesting and creative) MAKE ONE YOURSELF. THAT would have been cool - and interesting to read about. But. Nope. Buying used couches and furniture is so cute - but buying a second hand dress for a wedding is gross and making one is hard. 
There's nothing wrong with a blog that gives you a place to wonder out loud about where life is going, and to vent about nasty breakups, and the difficulties of life. Those things bring us closer together, because we know we are not the only ones going through these questions. But seriously, posts like this and several others, you two just come across like two spoiled little white girls who are staying out of the mall for a year - and lecturing us for crossing your personal picket line.”

3 comments:

  1. All I can say is, Stacey wasn't that dress a bridesmaids dress? Because those you don't buy used or make yourself...

    ~lauren foster

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yep, Lauren...that IS the case. And this was a very formal wedding, where you couldn't get away with straying too much.

    -Courtney (Stacey is away for the week, so I told her I'd keep up with things on the blog.)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm going to have to disagree 100% with this comment. Yes, some of the arguments made are valid but I think they completely miss the bigger picture. I speak from experience when I say that this blog has brought us closer together, and it has shifted my view on the way I live my life.

    How many blogs bring two complete strangers together from opposite sides of the nation? To me, that is so much bigger than not buying anything new.


    This blog has inspired me to take actions I otherwise would not have taken, and I can say with absolute certainty that those actions have impacted hundreds of people. It's about awareness, service to others, loving unconditionally even when it hurts... and the confessions in the blog just prove that yeah, we all mess up, but we can keep moving forward.

    "To know even one life has breathed easier
    Because you have lived...
    This is to have succeeded."
    Say what you will, but this blog and even its pitfalls are a success.

    Thank you, Courtney and Stacey.

    ReplyDelete